What Are The Challenges In Developing A Universal Parainfluenza Vaccine?
Published on: January 31, 2025
What Are The Challenges In Developing A Universal Parainfluenza Vaccine?
Article author photo

Teranee Astwood

Article reviewer photo

Azuka Chinweokwu Ezeike

MBBS, FWACS(Obstetrics and Gynaecology), FMCOG, MSc(Public Health)

Introduction

Parainfluenza viruses (PIVs) are a major cause of respiratory illnesses in children, particularly infants and toddlers. These viruses can cause a range of symptoms, leading to significant discomfort and potential complications. According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), PIVs account for an estimated 15% of all hospitalizations for bronchiolitis in the United States each year.1

Current treatments for PIV infections are limited. There are no specific antiviral medications available, and management primarily involves supportive care measures. Researchers are developing innovative vaccines that could be a game-changer for children's health. "Viral vector" vaccines are a promising weapon in the fight against PIV, offering a powerful path to stopping infections entirely. With this kind of protection, children would be less susceptible to these respiratory illnesses. A universal vaccine, offering broad protection against different PIV strains, would be a significant advancement in protecting children from these illnesses.

Parainfluenza viruses (PIVs)

There are four main types of PIVs (PIV 1-4), each causing a spectrum of respiratory illnesses. Here's a breakdown of the specific symptoms associated with each type:

  • PIV 1: This type is most commonly associated with croup, a condition characterized by a barking cough, hoarse voice, and difficulty breathing caused by inflammation of the upper airway2
  • PIV 2: This type typically causes milder illnesses similar to the common cold, with symptoms like runny nose, congestion, cough, and low-grade fever2
  • PIV 3: Similar to PIV 1, PIV 3 can cause croup, but it can also lead to bronchiolitis, an inflammation of the small airways in the lungs, causing wheezing and difficulty breathing2
  • PIV 4: This type of PIV is a real troublemaker for babies, often leading to bronchiolitis, a serious lung infection.2 Symptoms may include wheezing, cough, congestion, and difficulty feeding

PIVs spread through respiratory droplets expelled by coughing or sneezing. It spreads easily, so children in daycare, crowded spaces, or with older siblings who might bring germs home are more at risk of getting infected. Children with weaker immune systems because of health problems are more likely to get sick from PIV infections.3

The immune response to PIVs is complex. While the body develops antibodies after infection, these antibodies may not be effective against all PIV strains due to the viruses' ability to change structure and function. This explains why people can experience repeated PIV infections throughout their lives.

Current PIV treatments

Unfortunately, there are no specific antiviral medications available to treat PIV infections.4 Treatment focuses on managing symptoms and preventing complications. Supportive care measures like rest, fluids, and medications for fever and congestion are the mainstay of treatment. A humidifier can help loosen mucus and ease congestion. In severe cases, especially with bronchiolitis, oxygen therapy or hospitalization may be required to assist with breathing difficulties.5

While supportive treatments like fluid and rest can help ease symptoms of PIV infections, they can't always prevent serious complications, especially in vulnerable children. These can include dehydration, ear infections (otitis media), and in rare cases, pneumonia.6 While PIV infections might seem like common colds, hospitalization rates paint a different picture. Young children and those with compromised immune systems are most at risk for serious complications.

The concept of a universal PIV vaccine

A universal vaccine is designed to provide broad protection against a wide range of related viruses. In the context of PIVs, a universal vaccine would ideally offer immunity against all four major types (PIV 1-4). A successful PIV vaccine could be a game-changer It could dramatically decrease the number of PIV infections in children, leading to fewer hospital stays, less strain on healthcare systems, and overall better health for kids 

Challenges in developing a universal PIV vaccine

Developing a universal PIV vaccine presents several significant challenges:

Viral diversity

PIVs exhibit a high degree of antigenic diversity.7 This means that the surface proteins of the virus, which are the targets of the immune system, can mutate frequently. PIVs are constantly mutating which makes it tough for our bodies to recognise them. This also means vaccines that worked against older versions of PIV might not be effective against new ones.

Immune response 

Our understanding of the immune response to PIVs is still evolving. The big hurdle for scientists is pinpointing those specific defences within the immune system that can act like a shield against all PIV strains. This would be a major breakthrough in developing a universal vaccine. The immune response to PIVs involves both humoral immunity (antibody production) and cell-mediated immunity (activation of T cells).8 A universal vaccine would ideally stimulate both arms of the immune system for robust and long-lasting protection.

Vaccine design and development

PIVs are like some viruses that can change their appearance over time (mutate). To make a vaccine extra effective, scientists focus on parts of the virus that are less likely to change. This way, the vaccine can offer broad protection against many different variations of the virus. While targeting unchanging parts of PIVs seems like a good idea for a vaccine, it can be tricky. These unchanging regions might not be very "interesting" to our immune system. They might not trigger a strong response therefore the vaccine might not be as effective as we'd like. Various vaccine platforms are being explored for universal PIV vaccines. There are quite a few possibilities for PIV vaccines:

  • Subunit Vaccines: Imagine PIVs are like puzzle pieces, and some pieces (conserved regions) stay the same across different strains 9. Subunit vaccines are like taking just those unchanging pieces and showing them to your body's defence system. This way, your body can learn to recognize and fight off any PIV invader, no matter which other puzzle pieces they might have!
  • Viral Vector Vaccines: This type of vaccine uses a modified virus, such as a weakened adenovirus, to deliver the PIV antigens into the body's cells.10 The modified virus cannot cause illness but triggers the immune system to recognize and develop immunity against the PIV antigens it carries. This information tells our cells how to make special proteins that match PIVs (like blueprints). Due to this, these vaccines can trigger two ways our body fights infection (humoral and cell-mediated immunity). This two-pronged approach makes them very promising for creating a universal PIV vaccine, one that works against many different strains. These PIV vaccines hold promise, but scientists need to iron out some kinks to make them work best. Safety and people's existing immunity to the carrier virus are top priorities.

Clinical trials

Testing these universal PIV vaccines is a real puzzle. Scientists need to figure out the best way to make sure the vaccine protects against all the different PIV strains people might encounter. A large sample size with a very diverse population is needed to test the vaccine's effectiveness against different PIV strains present in the world. This can be a lengthy and expensive process. As children are the ones who will most benefit from this vaccine, researchers are extra careful to make sure everything is done ethically. This means getting informed consent from parents and closely monitoring the children throughout the trials to minimize any risks.

Ongoing research and future directions

Despite the challenges, research efforts towards developing a universal PIV vaccine are ongoing. Scientists are testing out some very promising approaches to PIV vaccines! These potential vaccines, some built like tiny compartments carrying key pieces of the virus (subunit vaccines), and others using a safe version of a different virus to deliver PIV protection (viral vector vaccines), are currently undergoing thorough testing in labs and with volunteers (preclinical and clinical trials).11 There's promising research happening right now in the US: 

  • The National Institutes of Health is funding the development of a special PIV vaccine. This vaccine is cleverly designed to hit common targets across three PIV strains, providing comprehensive protection for children against these respiratory illnesses
  • Several pharmaceutical companies are developing viral vector vaccines for PIVs. These vaccines are in various stages of preclinical and clinical development

Advancements in vaccine technology offer hope for the future. Scientists are constantly working to improve vaccines, and PIV vaccines are no exception. New ingredients called adjuvants are being developed to give subunit vaccines a bigger punch.12 These adjuvants are like little helpers that boost the immune system's response to the vaccine, making it more effective.

Another exciting area of research involves novel delivery systems, like tiny nanoparticles.13 These microscopic carriers can potentially deliver the vaccine more efficiently to the right cells in the body, leading to a stronger immune response.

Conclusion

Developing a universal PIV vaccine is no easy feat. The viruses themselves are constantly changing, making it difficult to target them effectively. Additionally, scientists are still learning more about how our bodies fight off PIVs. Designing a vaccine that works against all these challenges is complex.

But the potential rewards are huge! A successful vaccine could dramatically reduce the number of children hospitalized with PIV infections. This would not only improve public health but potentially lower healthcare costs as well.

There's exciting progress being made on a universal PIV vaccine! New research, clever technologies, and teamwork between different countries are all paving the way to protect children from these serious respiratory illnesses.

References

  1. Human Parainfluenza Viruses (HPIVs) | CDC. www.cdc.gov [Internet]. 2021. Available from: https://www.cdc.gov/parainfluenza/index.html.
  2. Elboukari H, Ashraf M. Parainfluenza Virus. In: PubMed [Internet]. Treasure Island (FL): StatPearls Publishing; 2021. Available from: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK560719/.
  3. Jakab Z. Children’s immature immune systems threatened by increasing “superbugs.” In: www.who.int [Internet]. 2020. Available from: https://www.who.int/news-room/commentaries/detail/children-s-immature-immune-systems-threatened-by-increasing-superbugs.
  4. Boncristiani HF, Criado MF, Arruda E. Respiratory Viruses. Encyclopedia of Microbiology. 2009; 500–18.
  5. Lorente Sánchez S, Gimeno R, Losilla J-M, Garzón S, Vives J. Benefits of the humidified low-flow oxygen therapy in infants with mild-moderate bronchiolitis. Journal of Clinical Nursing. 2018; 27(5-6):1125–33.
  6. Heidemann SM. Clinical characteristics of parainfluenza virus infection in hospitalized children. Pediatric Pulmonology. 1992; 13(2):86–9.
  7. Shao N, Liu B, Xiao Y, Wang X, Ren L, Dong J, et al. Genetic Characteristics of Human Parainfluenza Virus Types 1–4 From Patients With Clinical Respiratory Tract Infection in China. Frontiers in Microbiology. 2021; 12.
  8. Gul A, Khan S, Arshad M, Anjum SI, Attaullah S, Ali I, et al. Peripheral blood T cells response in human parainfluenza virus-associated lower respiratory tract infection in children. Saudi Journal of Biological Sciences. 2020.
  9. Morein B, Sharp M, Sundquist B, Simons K. Protein subunit vaccines of parainfluenza type 3 virus: immunogenic effect in lambs and mice. The Journal of General Virology [Internet]. 1983 [cited 2024 May 10]; 64 (Pt 7):1557–69. Available from: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/6306152/.
  10. Z C. Parainfluenza Virus 5-vectored Vaccines Against Human and Animal Infectious Diseases. In: Reviews in medical virology [Internet]. 2018. Available from: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29316047/.
  11. Schmidt AC, Schaap-Nutt A, Bartlett EJ, Schomacker H, Boonyaratanakornkit J, Karron RA, et al. Progress in the development of human parainfluenza virus vaccines. Expert review of respiratory medicine [Internet]. 2011; 5(4):515–26. Available from: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3503243/.
  12. Recommendations announced for influenza vaccine composition for the 2024-2025 northern hemisphere influenza season. www.who.int [Internet]. 2024. Available from: https://www.who.int/news/item/23-02-2024-recommendations-announced-for-influenza-vaccine-composition-for-the-2024-2025-northern-hemisphere-influenza-season.
  13. Liu X, Zheng L, Wang T, Li Y, Wu B, Du S, et al. A System Based on Novel Parainfluenza Virus PIV5-L for Efficient Gene Delivery of B-Lymphoma Cells. Journal of Virology. American Society for Microbiology; 2022; 96(8).
Share

Teranee Astwood

arrow-right